Some MRT trains have cars featuring 12 seats each. Passengers take the trains to travel from station to station each day. Seats located nearest to the train doors are labelled as priority seats reserved for vulnerable commuters, namely those who are pregnant, elderly, with infants, or the differently-abled. Anyone can sit at the priority seats if there are sufficient seats for all vulnerable commuters in the car. For one trip, 12 passengers, of which 4 are vulnerable commuters, got onto Car B at the first station.

- (a)
Given that all the vulnerable commuters are seated at priority seats, find the total number of ways all the 12 passengers can all sit in Car B.
- (b)
Find the number of ways the 12 passengers can be seated in Car B if
- (i)
two particular girls are seated in the same row but not beside each other.
- (ii)
exactly 4 of the 5 girls are seated together.
- (i)
It won't just hand you the answer — it asks where you're stuck.How the checker works
Worked solution
8(a)
1. Determine the number of ways to seat the 4 vulnerable commuters in the 4 priority seats.
There are exactly priority seats in Car B. The vulnerable commuters must sit in these seats.
Number of ways to seat them =
2. Determine the number of ways to seat the remaining passengers and calculate the total number of arrangements.
There are remaining passengers to be seated in the ordinary seats.
Number of ways to seat them =
Total number of ways =
8(b)(i)
1. Calculate the total number of ways to arrange all 12 passengers without any restrictions.
2. Calculate the number of ways to arrange the passengers such that the 2 particular girls are seated together, by treating them as a single grouped unit.
There are units to arrange (10 individual passengers + 1 group of 2 girls).
3. Subtract the number of ways they sit together from the total unrestricted ways to find the number of arrangements where they are not beside each other.
8(b)(ii)
1. Find the number of ways to select and arrange 4 out of the 5 girls to sit together.
Choose 4 girls to form a group and arrange them within the group:
2. Find the number of ways to arrange the remaining 7 passengers.
There are other passengers.
3. Use the gap method to place the group of 4 girls and the remaining 1 girl so they are separated.
The 7 other passengers create available spaces (including the ends of the row). To ensure exactly 4 girls are together, the group of 4 girls and the single remaining girl must be placed in different spaces.
4. Calculate the total number of valid seating arrangements.
Multiply the number of ways from the independent choices:
AI analysis — may contain mistakes.
Worked this one out on paper? Snap your steps and Gigle's AI math checker will circle the step where it went wrong.
More questions on this topic
- 1Eight students are shortlisted to be prize recipients for a competition. Two students are awarded the first prize and an…
- 2A personality test assesses 32 key traits. These 32 traits are grouped into 4 domains - Cognition, Influence, Rapport an…
- 3An amateur music composer is arranging a sequence of four musical notes followed by three beats. There are 7 possible no…
- 4Two brothers Kai and Leo are duathlon (running and cycling) athletes who train regularly. For each day, the probability…
- 5Colour Vision Deficiency is the decreased ability to see differences in colours. Someone with normal colour vision will…